diff --git a/.forge/runtime-role-matrix-live-20260714105818-v9-reviewer-001-attempt-2-run-202548711b4c.md b/.forge/runtime-role-matrix-live-20260714105818-v9-reviewer-001-attempt-2-run-202548711b4c.md deleted file mode 100644 index fbacdab..0000000 --- a/.forge/runtime-role-matrix-live-20260714105818-v9-reviewer-001-attempt-2-run-202548711b4c.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,3 +0,0 @@ -# runtime-role-matrix-live-20260714105818-v9-reviewer-001-attempt-2-run-202548711b4c - -Forge 이슈 작업 브랜치 `forge/runtime-role-matrix-live-20260714105818-v9-reviewer-001-attempt-2-run-202548711b4c`. diff --git a/docs/evidence/verification-results.txt b/docs/evidence/verification-results.txt deleted file mode 100644 index 400cbc6..0000000 --- a/docs/evidence/verification-results.txt +++ /dev/null @@ -1,35 +0,0 @@ -================================================================================ -VERIFICATION RESULTS - reviewer-smoke-001 -================================================================================ -Scope: docs-only-changes -Date: 2026-07-14T10:58:18Z -================================================================================ - -CHANGED FILES (4 files): --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -1. docs/reviewer-role-spec.md [EXISTS] [VALID] -2. docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json [EXISTS] [VALID JSON] -3. docs/reviewer-verification-report.md [EXISTS] [VALID] -4. docs/evidence/verification-results.txt [EXISTS] [VALID] - -VERIFICATION ITEMS (8 total): --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -V-001: File Existence Check [PASS] -V-002: JSON Syntax Validation [PASS] -V-003: Markdown Syntax Validation [PASS] -V-004: Checklist-Report Consistency [PASS] -V-005: Change File List Accuracy [PASS] -V-006: No Invalid Src References [PASS] -V-007: Evidence Completeness [PASS] -V-008: UTF-8 Encoding [PASS] - -SUMMARY: --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -Total: 8 | Passed: 8 | Failed: 0 | Pass Rate: 100% - -NOTES: --------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- No src/main/java or src/test/java files were modified -- All verification items have independent command evidence -- Change file list matches actual repository state -================================================================================ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/reviewer-role-spec.md b/docs/reviewer-role-spec.md deleted file mode 100644 index 2f03d53..0000000 --- a/docs/reviewer-role-spec.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,45 +0,0 @@ -# Reviewer Role Specification - -## Overview - -The Reviewer role is responsible for validating documentation changes and ensuring verification reports accurately reflect the actual state of the repository. - -## Responsibilities - -1. **Documentation Accuracy**: Verify that all documented changes match actual file modifications -2. **Evidence Completeness**: Ensure each verification item has independent, verifiable evidence -3. **Scope Consistency**: Report only on files that were actually changed - -## Verification Criteria - -### File Existence -- All listed files must exist in the repository -- No phantom references to non-existent files - -### Evidence Requirements -- Each verification item must include: - - Command executed - - Expected result - - Actual command output - - Pass/Fail status - -### Scope Boundaries -- Verification scope must match change scope -- If only docs/ files changed, do not report on src/ files -- If only src/ files changed, do not report on docs/ files - -## Smoke Test Criteria - -| Criterion | Description | -|-----------|-------------| -| File List Accuracy | Changed files list matches actual modifications | -| Evidence Independence | Each item has command output evidence | -| Scope Consistency | Verification scope matches change scope | -| Syntax Validity | JSON files are parseable | -| Encoding | All files are UTF-8 encoded | - -## Previous Issues (Resolved) - -1. **Mismatched File Lists**: Fixed by ensuring verification-results.txt lists only actual changed files -2. **Missing Evidence**: Fixed by adding command_output fields to all verification items -3. **Invalid Scope**: Fixed by limiting verification to docs/ files only (no src/ references) \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json b/docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json deleted file mode 100644 index 320c2a3..0000000 --- a/docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json +++ /dev/null @@ -1,106 +0,0 @@ -{ - "verification_id": "reviewer-smoke-001", - "scope": "docs-only-changes", - "changed_files": [ - "docs/reviewer-role-spec.md", - "docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json", - "docs/reviewer-verification-report.md", - "docs/evidence/verification-results.txt" - ], - "verification_items": [ - { - "id": "V-001", - "category": "file-existence", - "description": "변경 파일 존재 여부 확인", - "command": "ls -la docs/ docs/evidence/", - "expected": "4개 파일 모두 존재", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "docs/reviewer-role-spec.md exists\ndocs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json exists\ndocs/reviewer-verification-report.md exists\ndocs/evidence/verification-results.txt exists" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-002", - "category": "file-syntax", - "description": "JSON 파일 문법 검증", - "command": "cat docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json | python3 -m json.tool > /dev/null && echo 'VALID JSON'", - "expected": "VALID JSON", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "VALID JSON" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-003", - "category": "file-syntax", - "description": "Markdown 파일 문법 검증", - "command": "head -20 docs/reviewer-role-spec.md", - "expected": "Markdown 헤더 구조 확인", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "# Reviewer Role Specification\n## Overview\n## Responsibilities\n## Verification Criteria" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-004", - "category": "content-consistency", - "description": "체크리스트와 보고서 일관성", - "command": "grep -c 'PASS\|FAIL' docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json && grep -c 'PASS\|FAIL' docs/reviewer-verification-report.md", - "expected": "동일한 검증 항목 수", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "Checklist: 4 verification items\nReport: References same 4 items" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-005", - "category": "content-consistency", - "description": "변경 파일 목록과 검증 대상 일치", - "command": "cat docs/evidence/verification-results.txt", - "expected": "docs/ 4개 파일만 언급", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "verification-results.txt contains only docs/ directory files:\n- docs/reviewer-role-spec.md\n- docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json\n- docs/reviewer-verification-report.md\n- docs/evidence/verification-results.txt" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-006", - "category": "no-src-references", - "description": "src/ 파일에 대한 잘못된 검증 결과 없음", - "command": "grep -E 'src/main|src/test' docs/reviewer-verification-report.md || echo 'NO SRC REFERENCES'", - "expected": "NO SRC REFERENCES", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "NO SRC REFERENCES" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-007", - "category": "evidence-completeness", - "description": "각 검증 항목에 명령어 출력 포함", - "command": "grep -c 'command_output' docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json", - "expected": "모든 항목에 evidence.command_output 존재", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "6 items with command_output fields" - }, - "status": "PASS" - }, - { - "id": "V-008", - "category": "file-encoding", - "description": "UTF-8 인코딩 확인", - "command": "file docs/*.md docs/*.json docs/evidence/*.txt", - "expected": "UTF-8 인코딩", - "evidence": { - "command_output": "All files: UTF-8 Unicode text" - }, - "status": "PASS" - } - ], - "summary": { - "total": 8, - "passed": 8, - "failed": 0, - "verification_date": "2026-07-14T10:58:18Z" - } -} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/reviewer-verification-report.md b/docs/reviewer-verification-report.md deleted file mode 100644 index 6a217de..0000000 --- a/docs/reviewer-verification-report.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,93 +0,0 @@ -# Reviewer Role Verification Report - -## Overview - -| Item | Value | -|------|-------| -| Verification ID | reviewer-smoke-001 | -| Scope | docs-only-changes | -| Date | 2026-07-14T10:58:18Z | -| Status | PASS | - -## Changed Files (Actual) - -This verification covers only the following 4 files that were actually changed: - -| File Path | Type | Verification | -|-----------|------|--------------| -| `docs/reviewer-role-spec.md` | Markdown | V-003 | -| `docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json` | JSON | V-001, V-002 | -| `docs/reviewer-verification-report.md` | Markdown | V-004, V-006 | -| `docs/evidence/verification-results.txt` | Text | V-001, V-005 | - -**Note:** No `src/main/java` or `src/test/java` files were modified in this change set. - -## Verification Results - -### V-001: File Existence Check -- **Command:** `ls -la docs/ docs/evidence/` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** All 4 files exist in the repository - -### V-002: JSON Syntax Validation -- **Command:** `cat docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json | python3 -m json.tool > /dev/null` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** JSON syntax is valid - -### V-003: Markdown Syntax Validation -- **Command:** `head -20 docs/reviewer-role-spec.md` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** Markdown headers properly structured - -### V-004: Checklist-Report Consistency -- **Command:** Compare verification items -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** Both documents reference the same 4 changed files - -### V-005: Change File List Accuracy -- **Command:** `cat docs/evidence/verification-results.txt` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** Only docs/ directory files are listed - -### V-006: No Invalid Src References -- **Command:** `grep -E 'src/main|src/test' docs/reviewer-verification-report.md` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** No references to non-existent src/ files - -### V-007: Evidence Completeness -- **Command:** `grep -c 'command_output' docs/reviewer-verification-checklist.json` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** All 8 verification items have command_output fields - -### V-008: UTF-8 Encoding -- **Command:** `file docs/*.md docs/*.json docs/evidence/*.txt` -- **Result:** PASS -- **Evidence:** All files are UTF-8 encoded - -## Summary - -| Metric | Value | -|--------|-------| -| Total Verification Items | 8 | -| Passed | 8 | -| Failed | 0 | -| Pass Rate | 100% | - -## Issues Fixed from Previous Review - -1. **이전 문제:** `verification-results.txt`가 존재하지 않는 src/ 파일을 NEW로 표시 - - **수정:** docs/ 4개 파일만 정확히 나열 - -2. **이전 문제:** 체크리스트에 실제 증거 없이 모든 항목이 PASS - - **수정:** 각 항목에 `command_output` 필드로 구체적 증거 포함 - -3. **이전 문제:** 변경되지 않은 src/ 파일에 대한 검증 결과 포함 - - **수정:** 검증 범위를 docs/ 파일로 제한 - -## Smoke Test Criteria - -- [x] 변경 파일 목록이 정확함 -- [x] 검증 범위가 변경 파일과 일치함 -- [x] 각 검증 항목에 독립적 증거 존재 -- [x] JSON 문법이 유효함 -- [x] 인코딩이 UTF-8임 \ No newline at end of file